Service Dog Life > Is a Service Dog for You? (publicly viewable board)

looking for help with Fake service dogs

(1/3) > >>

roommate105:
I live in an apartment with three other people. It works that we each have a room with a lock and we all share a common space. When I moved in, I found out that one of the girls had a "service" dog. It's 8 months old, but she tells people it's over a year. She bought a vest off amazon and uses that. Whenever someone's asked if its a service dog she rants and cries until people stop asking. The dog only knows a few basic tricks, but otherwise doesn't perform any task. The dog has growled at my friends and my dad when they've come over to the apartment. It's peed inside a couple times, too.
But now she (and her boyfriend that we've kicked out for living off us) have gotten a german shepherd puppy that's just now turned 3 months. It pees everywhere, chews on things, and barks at anything and everything. They've bought another vest for this dog now too. They've admitted that they don't want to pay the pet deposit, and that they just want to take the dogs with them places.
My roommates and I have tried talking to them, but they have a little bit of a complex when it comes to someone disagreeing with what they're doing. I don't know what to do, or if there's anything I really can do. Please give your opinions. I wish I knew more about this stuff.

Kirsten:
It doesn't matter whether they actually are service dogs or not. If they are not house broken or are aggressive, you can kick the animals out.

From a roommate perspective, it doesn't matter if they are legitimate service dogs or not. You don't have to agree to live with them. The catch is that you have already agreed to live with the first one.  The landlord is bound by the fair housing act. You, as roommates, are not.

I suppose the roommates agree on what they want and tell the pet owning roommate what the rules are. Then vote her off the island if she does not comply. This is contingent on what your existing agreement with her is and who is on the lease and what the lease says. It's complicated enough you should consult an attorney before taking any action. But you can still discuss whether it is enough of a problem you want to consult an attorney to actually do something about it.

Arrowcom:
Does your landlord know the laws? Have they seen the damages the dog has done to the apartment? Would it help if we directed you to a print off of some laws that you could give to your landlord? Have you told them of the situation? If I were you and your other roommate, I would vote them out like Kirsten said. Even trying to ignore my extreme bias as someone who is hurt by people who pass their pets off as working dogs, the general mayhem these dogs seem to be causing is reason enough to kick them out, even if they were just pets. 

roommate105:
The landlord kind of knows whats up. The office is run by student workers, and i'm sure they don't know what to do. The puppy isn't even supposed to be here. If you could point me to a list of laws and such, that'd be a lot of help.

Kirsten:
It's not as simple as a list of laws. It's one law, the Fair Housing Act, aka Title 8 of the Civil Rights Act, except it never mentions dogs or animals of any kind. This is why you need an attorney, to help you interpret the law in your situation.

You could flip it on her and ask her to show you where in the law it says you must permit it.  Because it doesn't. The FHAct applies to landlords, not to roommates. That much is made clear in the act itself.

If you want to look through case law, rulings of different courts applying the FHAct in different situations, we have a collection of those on the front end of the site. But an attorney will do a much more complete search than you can do online. Only some courts release their rulings online. Lawyers can access them all, whether online or not. A lawyer is also specially trained to know how other laws interact and modify a law. For example, the ADA says businesses must permit service animals on their premises, but this does not apply to churches or private clubs. Why? Because of the first amendment to the constitution.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

Sitemap 
Go to full version